Last updated

When the swimming area at Plattsburgh City Beach closed for the season on Tuesday 1 September, the mayor gave a reason that surprises most people who hear it: there is no such thing as swim at your own risk at a permitted bathing beach in New York. No lifeguards means no swimming, and that is a health department rule rather than a policy choice.
Plattsburgh Mayor Wendell Hughes told North Country Public Radio that the beach lost its guards to the school calendar: the college students had already gone back and the remaining high school students were starting classes and sports. “There is no such thing as, ‘Swim at your own risk,'” he said. “There’s either lifeguard swimming or no swimming, so that’s what will be posted.” That sentence is the clearest public statement of a rule operators across the state work under and most swimmers have never read.
Key facts
- Under New York’s State Sanitary Code, 10 NYCRR 6-2.16(a), “Bathing shall be prohibited where required supervision is not provided.” Posting a sign that moves the risk onto the swimmer is not one of the available options.
- Section 6-2.16(b) requires operators to post the hours during which bathing is allowed and to state that bathing at any other time is prohibited. The sign is a schedule, not a waiver.
- At beaches on Supervision Level I or II, 10 NYCRR 6-2.17(a)(4) requires at least one aquatic supervisory staff member for each 50 yards of beach front or fraction of it, and enough staff to keep the entire open bathing area under visual surveillance.
- Once a beach needs three or more aquatic supervisory staff, section 6-2.17(a)(8) requires a supervising lifeguard on top of them.
- A Level IIb pool and beach lifeguard in New York must be at least 16 (15 is allowed if a supervisory lifeguard is present), must hold professional rescuer CPR whose certification period does not exceed one year, and must be able to swim 300 yards nonstop, surface dive to a minimum nine foot depth and bring a 10 pound object up, and tread water for one minute (10 NYCRR 6-2.20(b)).
- American Aquatics and Safety Training runs CPR/AED as 275 minutes (4 hours 35 minutes) in the classroom or 170 minutes (2 hours 50 minutes) of instructor-led time in the blended format, marks the written test at 80 percent, and always conducts the skills evaluation in person.
The closure was a calendar problem, not a hiring problem
It is easy to file a story like this under the lifeguard shortage and move on, but the closure describes something narrower and more fixable. The beach had guards all summer, and two on duty on its final morning. What it ran out of was guards still available in September, because the roster was built from college and high school students and the school year restarted before Labor Day did. Labor Day fell late in 2026, which widened the gap between the end of the student labour supply and the end of the posted season.
That gap is predictable to the week, and it is the part of the season most operators plan for last. A summer roster is recruited in the spring, when the applicants are students because students are the people who are free in July. The same feature that makes it easy to fill in June makes it collapse on a fixed date at the end of August. Nothing about the water changes on that date. Only the supervision does, and in New York the supervision is what the permit is built around.
What New York actually requires before anyone can swim
The state does not set one universal rule for every beach. Subpart 6-2 assigns each regulated bathing beach a supervision level driven by the hazards present rather than by the size of the crowd. Level I is the surf lifeguard standard, required at ocean surf beaches. Level IIb, the pool and beach lifeguard standard, is triggered by any of a specific list of conditions: water depth of five feet or more inside the designated bathing area, diving boards, flotation devices other than Coast Guard Type I to III, bottom conditions hazardous to bathers, aquatic amusements, a bathing area perimeter 50 feet or more from shore, a beach bottom slope steeper than 1:8, or slides that discharge into the water.
Supervision Level IV, the lightest tier, is available only where the designated bathing area is less than five feet deep and its perimeter is less than 50 feet from shore. Even then it is not unsupervised swimming. It requires two or more adults aged 18 or over present whenever the beach is in use with at least one on the beachfront, a documented visual check before use, a logged record of inspection times and bather numbers, a free telephone with emergency numbers posted, and a warning sign of at least 36 by 24 inches. A lake beach whose swim zone reaches deeper than five feet, which describes most municipal beaches, cannot drop to that tier at all.
Underneath all of it sits 10 NYCRR 6-2.18, which requires a daily record of bather numbers, lifeguards on duty, weather, water clarity, water quality results, and any rescues, injuries or illnesses, held at the facility for 12 months. Coverage is not just required; it is written down every day and available to the permit-issuing official on inspection. An operator who quietly left the water open with nobody watching it would be creating the evidence against themselves.
Expert view
“People hear ‘no lifeguard on duty’ and read it as an instruction to swim carefully,” says Jackie Stern, Lifeguard Instructor, Firefighter and EMT, who reviews course content for American Aquatics and Safety Training. “At a permitted bathing facility it does not mean that. It means the water is closed, and closing it is the operator’s decision made before anyone gets in, not the swimmer’s decision made afterwards. The standard exists because supervision is the thing that turns a drowning into a rescue, and there is no wording on a sign that does that job.”
What operators and swimmers should take from this
For operators, the shoulder season is a staffing problem with a known date attached. Build the September roster separately from the July one, recruiting from people whose availability does not end with the school year. Stagger the annual professional rescuer CPR renewals so the whole team does not come due in the same fortnight, since New York caps that certification period at one year while the lifeguard training certificate itself can run up to three. And decide in advance what the beach will post, because the choice under 6-2.16 is between guarded swimming and closed water.
For swimmers and parents, the reading is simpler. A closed swim zone is not a suggestion, and the surrounding facilities staying open does not mean the water has reopened. Plattsburgh is keeping its trails, dog park and restrooms available into the autumn while the swimming area stays shut, which is the normal pattern.
If you are hiring or certifying aquatic staff, our waterfront lifeguarding classes and CPR/AED classes cover the skills these rules are written around, and our New York course listings show what is scheduled locally.
Sources
- Plattsburgh City Beach swim area closed due to lifeguard staffing issues (NCPR, 1 Sep 2026)
- 10 NYCRR 6-2.16, Control of beach and water use
- 10 NYCRR 6-2.17, Supervision, personnel and equipment
- 10 NYCRR 6-2.18, Operator and operating records
- 10 NYCRR 6-2.20, Aquatic supervisory skill requirements
- New York State Sanitary Code, Subpart 6-2 Bathing Beaches (NYSDOH)
Reviewed by Jackie Stern, Lifeguard Instructor, Firefighter and EMT. Jackie Stern has taught lifeguarding for more than 20 years and works as a firefighter, EMT and swim instructor. She reviews course content, prerequisites and rescue standards against current certification requirements.