Who Actually Performs CPR in a School: What a Cardiac Emergency Response Plan Has to Cover

Last updated

Who Actually Performs CPR in a School: What a Cardiac Emergency Response Plan Has to Cover

A cardiac emergency response plan is about to stop being optional in Minnesota, and the people who used one at Mabel-Canton School were not the people most plans train. The Fillmore County Journal reported that Superintendent Michael Harvey told the school board on 18 August 2026 that two custodial staff joined a construction lead superintendent and an electrical contractor to give CPR to an inspector who collapsed on site, using the school’s AED. “Using our AED and CPR, they saved this person’s life,” Harvey said. No nurse, no coach and no athletic trainer appears in that list.

Key facts

  • Minnesota Statutes section 121A.241 requires every school district and charter school to develop a written cardiac emergency response plan beginning in the 2026-2027 school year.
  • The statute lists seven things the plan must do, including establishing a cardiac emergency response team, placing and maintaining AEDs to nationally recognized cardiovascular care guidelines, distributing the plan in coordination with local EMS, running annual drills for staff and students, and covering athletic events held off school grounds.
  • Minnesota separately requires one-time CPR and AED instruction with hands-on psychomotor skills practice for all students in grades 7 to 12 (Minn. Stat. 120B.236). That instruction does not have to result in a certification.
  • New York reaches the same problem from the other end: Education Law 917 requires AEDs on site in every instructional school facility, and at least one trained staff member present at school-sponsored events including athletic contests held away from the campus.
  • An American Aquatics and Safety Training CPR/AED certification runs 275 minutes in the classroom (4 hours 35 minutes) or 170 minutes blended (2 hours 50 minutes), needs 80 percent on the written exam, and is valid for two years.
  • Skills are always evaluated in person, at a 1:10 instructor-to-student ratio and a 1:2 manikin ratio. There is no abbreviated recertification: a renewal is the full course.

The responders were the staff nobody plans for

Notice the job titles. Two custodians, a lead superintendent from the construction manager, a contractor from an electrical firm. None had a clinical role at the school, and two of the four did not work for the district.

This is the ordinary shape of a cardiac arrest in a school building, and it is why plans built around the school nurse tend to fail. A nurse covers one office during one set of hours. Arrests happen in the gym at 6 a.m., in a mechanical room during a summer inspection, in a parking lot at a Saturday game. The person standing closest is a custodian, a bus driver, a food service worker or a visiting contractor, and the outcome depends on whether that person starts compressions and finds the defibrillator in the first few minutes.

The gap is documented. In the CDC’s surveillance summary from the Cardiac Arrest Registry to Enhance Survival, covering October 2005 to December 2010, only 33.3 percent of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients received bystander CPR, and survival to hospital discharge was 9.6 percent overall against 11.3 percent among those who did. Those national figures are over a decade old and are not a verdict on any school, but they explain why states stopped treating “someone will help” as a plan.

What a cardiac emergency response plan actually has to contain

Minnesota’s requirement is short, and worth reading rather than paraphrasing from a vendor brochure. Section 121A.241 subdivision 2 says the plan must establish a cardiac emergency response team and a way to activate it during sudden cardiac arrest; place AEDs on school grounds following nationally recognized cardiovascular care organization guidelines; provide for their routine maintenance; distribute the plan on school grounds and in coordination with local EMS providers; run annual drills for staff and students; have the school board review the plan’s effectiveness every year; and say how staff must respond at school-sponsored activities, including athletic events on or off school grounds.

Three of those seven are the ones that get skipped. Routine AED maintenance is a calendar item, not a purchase: pads expire, batteries expire, and a cabinet nobody has opened in three years is a decoration. Distribution “in coordination with local emergency medical services providers” means the ambulance service has seen your building and knows which door to use. The annual drill is the only clause that tests whether the rest works, which is why it is the first thing dropped in a busy September.

The seventh clause, on off-campus athletic events, is the one New York already addresses head on: Education Law 917 requires the AED to travel to the away game with a trained person, clearly marked, accessible and maintained to nationally recognized guidelines. A district that satisfies the plan requirement on paper but leaves the defibrillator locked in the school on a Saturday has satisfied nothing.

What the training behind the plan involves

A plan names people who are trained, and the hours involved are smaller than most administrators assume. At AAST a CPR/AED class is 275 minutes of classroom time (4 hours 35 minutes), or 170 minutes (2 hours 50 minutes) blended, where the cognitive material is completed online first. Adding First Aid makes it 8 hours 35 minutes classroom or 4 hours 50 minutes blended. The written exam is passed at 80 percent, and the card is good for two years, after which the course is repeated in full because there is no shortened recertification path.

What cannot be compressed is the skills evaluation, always done in person with an instructor watching. Compression depth, rate, recoil, the pause before a shock and the handover between rescuers are motor skills, assessed at a 1:10 instructor-to-student ratio with no more than two students to a manikin. A team of eight custodial and maintenance staff is a single afternoon.

Expert view

“The point of a response plan is that nobody has to decide who is qualified while somebody is on the floor,” says Jackie Stern, Lifeguard Instructor, Firefighter and EMT, who reviews AAST course content. “Train the people who are physically in the building at odd hours, not just the people with health in their job title, and drill it once a year so finding the AED is muscle memory instead of a search.”

What districts and facility operators should do now

  • List every AED you own on one page, with location, pad expiry and battery expiry. If that page takes more than an hour to produce, the maintenance clause is already failing.
  • Count trained staff present at 6 a.m., at 6 p.m. and on a Saturday, not the roster total. Train to cover the gaps, starting with custodial, maintenance and transportation staff.
  • Put the annual drill on the calendar before the school year starts, with a date, not a term.
  • Decide now who carries the AED to away games, and check that it is the same answer in writing that the athletic director would give out loud.
  • Send the plan and a building map to your local ambulance service and ask which entrance they will use.

Mabel-Canton got the outcome every plan is written to produce, with four people who happened to be nearby and knew what to do. The statute exists to make that repeatable rather than fortunate.

Sources

Related reading

American Aquatics and Safety Training, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. Tax ID (EIN) 83-4426661.

70 E. Sunrise Highway, Suite 500, Valley Stream, NY 11581

About our organization

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.